Tags / dark fantasy

"dark fantasy"

41 BuzzVerdicts across TV Shows (9), PC Games (25), Books (5), Board Games (1), Mobile Games (1)

Over the Garden Wall

4.7

2014 · 1 Season · Cartoon Network · Animation, Fantasy, Mystery

Over the Garden Wall is a nearly perfect piece of animated storytelling. In just ten episodes totaling under two hours, it builds a haunting fairy-tale world, develops genuine emotional depth between its two leads, and delivers a narrative that rewards multiple viewings with new layers of meaning. The folk-inspired soundtrack by The Blasting Company is extraordinary, the visual design evokes classic illustration traditions, and the story knows exactly when to end. Minor quibbles about humor that occasionally falls flat or episodes that feel more atmospheric than substantive barely register against the cumulative power of the whole. This is the rare show that does everything it sets out to do and never overstays its welcome.

Elden Ring

4.7

2022 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Elden Ring took FromSoftware's demanding combat philosophy and dropped it into a vast open world that actually rewards exploration rather than punishing it. The freedom to choose your own path through the Lands Between means difficulty is partly self-regulated, making this the most approachable entry point to the Souls formula while still delivering the highs that veterans crave. Late-game balance issues and reused bosses dull the final stretch, but the first 60 or so hours represent some of the finest action RPG design ever put together. FromSoftware didn't just make their best game. They redefined what an open-world action RPG could feel like.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

4.7

2009 · 1 Season · MBS/TBS · Action / Adventure / Dark Fantasy

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood earns its place among the best anime ever produced through sheer ambition and follow-through. Sixty-four episodes build a world that feels lived-in, populate it with characters worth caring about, and tell a story that respects both its audience and its own rules. The rocky opening stretch and occasional comedy misfires are real flaws, but they're small cracks in something enormous and carefully constructed. This is the rare long-running series where the ending lands as hard as the beginning promises it will.

Dragon Age: Origins

4.5

2009 · RPG · PC / Steam

Dragon Age: Origins is BioWare's best RPG and one of the finest party-based RPGs ever made. Its companions are unforgettable, its origin stories give player choices weight from the first hour, and its dark fantasy world feels alive with political tension and moral ambiguity. Getting it to run on modern hardware requires patience and community fixes, but what's underneath those technical layers remains remarkable.

Thief II: The Metal Age

4.5

2000 · Stealth · PC / Steam

Thief II: The Metal Age took everything the original did right and refined it into a tighter, more consistent experience. By committing fully to urban stealth and eliminating the monster-heavy levels that dragged down its predecessor, Looking Glass Studios delivered a sequel that is widely regarded as the best stealth game ever made. The missions are larger, the tools are more versatile, and the level design rewards creative problem-solving in ways that feel truly open-ended. It looks as dated as the first game and lacks the surprise of playing something truly new, but what it offers in exchange is mastery. This is the series operating at its peak.

Against the Storm

4.5

2023 · City Builder / Roguelite Strategy · PC / Steam

Against the Storm is one of the smartest city builders in years, using roguelite structure to solve a problem that has plagued the genre forever. Each run is genuinely different, the tension never fully lets up, and the developers have kept improving it since launch. If you've ever bounced off city builders because they eventually stop surprising you, this one was designed with you in mind.

A Game of Thrones

4.5

1996 · George R.R. Martin · 694 pages · Epic Fantasy

A Game of Thrones rewrote the rules of fantasy fiction by refusing to follow them. Martin built a world where honor gets people killed, villains have sympathetic moments, and no character is safe from the consequences of their choices. The political intrigue is absorbing, the rotating perspectives keep the story unpredictable, and the willingness to make readers uncomfortable gives every scene real stakes. It's not for everyone. The violence is graphic, the cast is enormous, and the series it launches remains unfinished decades later. But as a standalone reading experience, this is one of the most gripping and consequential fantasy novels ever written.

Attack on Titan

4.5

2013 · 4 Seasons · MBS / NHK General TV · Action / Dark Fantasy

Attack on Titan starts as a survival horror story about humanity's last stand behind massive walls and ends as something far more ambitious, a sweeping political epic about freedom, hatred, and the cycles that perpetuate both. Across four seasons and nearly a decade of storytelling, it delivers some of the most jaw-dropping plot twists, emotionally devastating moments, and thematically rich material that the medium has ever produced. The ending divided its fanbase, and the pacing stumbles in both early and late stretches. Those are real flaws in an otherwise extraordinary piece of work. This is the kind of show that changes what you think anime can do, and its best moments will stay with you long after the final credits roll.

Dark Souls III

4.5

2016 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Dark Souls III is the most polished and accessible entry in the trilogy, delivering combat that's faster and more responsive than its predecessors alongside some of the best boss encounters FromSoftware has ever designed. Its more linear structure and heavy reliance on callbacks to the original Dark Souls will bother players who value the open exploration that defined the first game. Both DLC expansions, especially The Ringed City, are essential additions that push the combat and level design to their peaks. As a finale to one of gaming's most influential trilogies, it sends things off with the kind of challenge and atmosphere that made the series matter in the first place.

Hunter x Hunter (2011)

4.5

2011 · 1 Season · Nippon TV · Action / Adventure / Fantasy

Hunter x Hunter is one of the smartest and most emotionally ambitious action anime ever produced, and the 2011 adaptation by Madhouse does its source material justice at nearly every turn. The Nen power system remains the gold standard for how to make fictional combat feel strategic rather than arbitrary. Its willingness to shift genres across arcs, from adventure to heist thriller to war epic, keeps the show from ever settling into a predictable rhythm. The Chimera Ant arc's pacing will test anyone's patience, and the heavy narration in later episodes is a legitimate frustration. But the payoffs, both emotional and thematic, that the show delivers when it's operating at its peak put it in conversation with the best the medium has produced.

Path of Exile

4.5

2013 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Path of Exile is the action RPG that kept expanding while its competitors stood still. Over a decade of free updates have turned a scrappy alternative into the standard-bearer for the genre, with character customization depth that nothing else matches and a league system that reinvents the game every few months. The learning curve is brutal and the trading system is stuck in another era, but players who push past those barriers tend to stay for years. Grinding Gear Games built something that respects both your intelligence and your wallet, and in the free-to-play space, that combination remains vanishingly rare.

Thief: The Dark Project

4.3

1998 · Stealth · PC / Steam

Thief: The Dark Project invented the first-person stealth genre and did it with a confidence that still holds up. The sound design, the light-and-shadow mechanics, and the level design in its best missions create a tension that modern stealth games rarely match. Some later levels swap stealth for combat in ways that undermine the game's own strengths, and the visuals have aged past the point of nostalgia into genuine roughness. But the core design, the idea that darkness is your weapon and sound is your enemy, remains as compelling now as it was in 1998. This is where stealth gaming began, and the foundation it built is still the one the genre stands on.

Grim Dawn

4.3

2016 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Grim Dawn is one of the finest action RPGs available on PC, built on a foundation of extraordinary build diversity and deep character customization. Its dual-class system and Devotion constellation tree create a level of theorycrafting depth that keeps players experimenting for hundreds of hours. The world is grim and atmospheric, the loot loop is satisfying, and the modding community extends the game well beyond its already generous content. It won't win over players who want flashy, fast-paced combat, and it takes time to show its hand. For anyone willing to invest that time, though, this is the kind of game that quietly becomes an all-time favorite.

Castlevania

4.2

2017 · 4 Seasons · Netflix · Animation / Action / Dark Fantasy / Horror

Castlevania did something the entire entertainment industry had spent decades failing at: it turned a video game into a great television show. Four seasons of gorgeous animation, morally complex characters, and action choreography that set a new standard for the medium. The pacing stumbles in the back half, particularly once Dracula exits the stage, and some storylines in seasons three and four feel stretched thin. But the highs are extraordinary, the character work is far deeper than anyone expected from a Konami adaptation, and the fight sequences alone are worth the price of entry. This is the show that proved video game stories could work on screen.

Diablo II: Resurrected

4.2

2021 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Diablo II: Resurrected is a faithful and visually stunning remaster of one of the most important action RPGs ever made. The updated graphics bring the dark world of Sanctuary to life without compromising the gameplay that made the original a legend. Quality of life improvements like shared stash and auto gold pickup smooth out the roughest edges, and ongoing content updates have kept the game evolving. Some design choices haven't aged gracefully, and the rocky launch left scars on community trust. But the core experience, the loot chase, the build diversity, the satisfying rhythm of clearing dungeons, remains as compelling as it was two decades ago. For action RPG fans, this is essential.

Darkest Dungeon

4.2

2016 · Turn-Based RPG · PC / Steam

Darkest Dungeon is a game that wants you to feel the cost of every decision, and its stress system, atmospheric art, and punishing combat deliver on that promise completely. Red Hook Studios built something that feels fundamentally different from other dungeon crawlers, where managing your heroes' mental state matters as much as their hit points. The grind through the mid-game and the occasional run-ending RNG streak are real weaknesses that test player patience. But the atmosphere is unmatched, the narrator alone is worth experiencing, and the moments where a desperate gamble pays off create the kind of stories that keep players talking about this game years after release.

Jujutsu Kaisen

4.2

2020 · 3 Seasons · MBS / TBS · Action / Dark Fantasy / Supernatural

Jujutsu Kaisen delivers some of the best animated action sequences in modern anime, powered by a creative magic system and a willingness to let its characters suffer real consequences. MAPPA's production work is frequently stunning, and the show's refusal to pad itself with filler keeps the pace tight across its run. Its villain roster beyond the top tier can feel underdeveloped, and certain character arcs get cut short before they fully land. Still, this is a series that earns its place in the modern shounen conversation through sheer craft, ambition, and an appetite for darkness that most of its peers won't touch.

The Ocean at the End of the Lane

4.1

2013 · Neil Gaiman · 181 pages · Fantasy

Neil Gaiman's 2013 novella about a man revisiting the memories of a childhood encounter with something ancient and terrifying is his most personal and emotionally direct work. The Hempstock women are among his best creations, the childhood perspective is handled with unsettling accuracy, and Gaiman captures the way memory distorts and preserves in equal measure. At 181 pages, some readers wish it lingered longer in its world, and the mythological framework is left deliberately vague. But as a story about the things we forget because remembering them would be unbearable, The Ocean at the End of the Lane is Gaiman at his most affecting.

Blasphemous

4.0

2019 · Action Platformer · PC / Steam

Blasphemous is a striking metroidvania built on a foundation of religious horror, gorgeous pixel art, and punishing combat. The atmosphere and visual design are extraordinary, creating a world unlike anything else in the genre. Backtracking without enough fast travel points and some cryptic quest logic hold it back from greatness, but the sheer artistry on display carries it through those frustrations. Anyone drawn to dark, challenging platformers with a strong sense of identity should put this near the top of their list.

Made in Abyss

4.0

2017 · 2 Seasons · AT-X / Tokyo MX · Adventure / Fantasy / Drama

Made in Abyss creates one of the most compelling fictional worlds in anime history and then dares its characters, and its audience, to keep descending into it. The Abyss itself is a masterwork of environmental storytelling, gorgeous and terrifying in equal measure, with Kevin Penkin's soundtrack elevating every moment of wonder and dread. The show's willingness to inflict real suffering on its young protagonists gives the adventure genuine stakes but also pushes into territory that many viewers find deeply uncomfortable. Whether that discomfort represents brave storytelling or unnecessary provocation depends on your tolerance and your trust in the narrative. For those who can engage with it on its own terms, this is an unforgettable piece of anime that stays with you long after you stop watching.

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings

4.0

2011 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings is a dark fantasy RPG that treats its player like an adult, offering morally complex choices with real consequences and a branching story structure that few games have matched since. The combat has a steep learning curve and the pacing stumbles in places, but the writing quality and the boldness of its narrative design make it a landmark in the genre.

Diablo

4.0

1996 · Action RPG · PC / GOG

Diablo created a genre and did it with an atmosphere that nothing has matched since. The descent into the cathedral beneath Tristram is one of gaming's most iconic journeys, built on a loop of killing, looting, and pushing deeper that proved irresistible in 1996 and still works today. The gameplay is simple by modern standards, and the procedural generation can feel repetitive in extended sessions, but the mood never breaks. Blizzard North built something that transcended its technical limitations through sheer commitment to tone. Nearly three decades later, the original Diablo remains a game that every action RPG fan should experience at least once.

Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon

3.8

2019 · 1-4 Players · 60-120 min per session · Cooperative

Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon tells one of the best stories in tabletop gaming, wrapping a dark reimagining of Arthurian legend around a survival adventure that demands real commitment. The writing is exceptional, the choices carry genuine weight, and the atmosphere never lets up. A grinding resource loop and repetitive encounters drag down the middle hours of the campaign. But for players willing to push through the slower stretches, the narrative payoff is worth the investment, and very few games in the hobby can match the emotional territory it covers.

The Wraith's Haunt

3.8

2017 · Hugo Huesca · 332 pages · LitRPG

The Wraith's Haunt earns its reputation as one of the stronger LitRPG entries by blending dungeon building with character-driven dark fantasy, delivering a protagonist who feels earned rather than handed his power. An uneven second book and some pacing complaints keep it from the top tier, but the foundation Hugo Huesca builds here has kept readers coming back across five installments.

Gothic

3.8

2001 · RPG · PC / Steam

Gothic is a rough, uncompromising RPG that earns its cult status through world design and a progression system that makes every level-up feel like it matters. The mining colony under its magical barrier feels like a real, functioning society where factions compete for power and every NPC has a place. Combat demands patience and timing that the controls don't always support, and the interface fights you at nearly every turn. But the sense of growing from a helpless nobody into someone who can hold their own in this hostile world is more convincing here than in almost any other RPG. It's a game that rewards persistence, and for the players who push through the rough opening hours, it becomes one of the most memorable experiences the genre has to offer.

Tyranny

3.8

2016 · RPG · PC / Steam

Tyranny offers one of the most original premises in RPG history, casting you as a servant of evil in a world that's already lost. The writing is sharp, the choices feel meaningful, and few games let you explore morality from this angle. Its abrupt ending and underdeveloped companion arcs hold it back from greatness, and the combat won't convert anyone who bounced off the Pillars of Eternity system. For RPG fans hungry for something that actually asks different questions, Tyranny delivers a fascinating 20-to-30-hour experience. It just leaves you wishing Obsidian had been given the time to finish what they started.

Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty

3.7

2023 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty brings Team Ninja's signature combat design to a Three Kingdoms setting with impressive results. The deflect system and spirit gauge create a rhythm of aggressive, precise play that stands apart from other games in the soulslike genre, and the best boss fights rank among the studio's finest work. A repetitive second half, limited enemy variety, and a PC version that launched with significant performance problems keep it from reaching the heights of Team Ninja's previous titles. It's a flawed but rewarding action RPG that delivers on its combat promise even when the surrounding game can't always keep up.

Lords of the Fallen

3.5

2023 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Lords of the Fallen is an ambitious soulslike that gets its most distinctive feature right. The dual-world mechanic, powered by the Umbral Lamp, creates a layered exploration experience that no other game in the genre offers, and the gothic art direction gives the world a haunting visual identity. But ambition without execution only gets you so far. Performance issues, frustrating enemy density, uneven checkpoint spacing, and a second half that relies on overwhelming the player rather than challenging them hold the game back from the standard set by its inspirations. Extensive post-launch support has smoothed many of the roughest edges, making the current version a significantly better game than what launched in October 2023.

Mortal Shell

3.5

2020 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Mortal Shell is a focused, atmospheric take on the souls-like formula built by a team of roughly 15 people, and the ambition shows in both its best ideas and its limitations. The Harden mechanic is a smart and original addition to the genre's defensive toolkit, and the visual design punches far above what you'd expect from a studio this small. Limited weapon variety, a short runtime, and enemies that don't always match the quality of the game's systems keep it from standing shoulder to shoulder with the genre's heavyweights. It works best as a proof of concept, one that demonstrates real talent and leaves you wanting to see what Cold Symmetry does next.

Chainsaw Man

3.5

2022 · 1 Season · TV Tokyo · Action / Dark Fantasy / Horror

Chainsaw Man arrived as one of the most anticipated anime adaptations of its era and delivered something markedly different from what many fans expected. MAPPA's cinematic approach created a visually distinctive series with a moody, grounded atmosphere and excellent voice work, but that same stylistic choice became the center of a fierce debate among manga readers who wanted something faster and more vibrant. The writing remains sharp and the characters compelling, but the adaptation's deliberate restraint left a meaningful portion of the fanbase feeling the anime missed the manga's raw energy. It's a strong show that will land perfectly for some viewers and feel like a near miss for others.

Awaken Online: Catharsis

3.5

2016 · Travis Bagwell · 580 pages · Fantasy / LitRPG

Awaken Online: Catharsis takes the VRMMORPG LitRPG formula and darkens it, following a protagonist who embraces necromancy and villain gameplay as a cathartic escape from real-world bullying. The dark magic systems are creative, the underdog narrative is compelling, and the willingness to let its protagonist play the bad guy gives it an edge that most LitRPGs avoid. The real-world school bully subplot is heavy-handed, the AI overlord narrative raises questions the book isn't ready to answer, and the dark themes occasionally feel like edginess for its own sake.

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

3.5

2015 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is the definitive version of the most debated Souls game, bundling all three DLC expansions with remixed enemy and item placements. It's a massive action RPG with strong PvP, excellent DLC content, and enough build variety to sustain hundreds of hours. It's also the entry that makes you work hardest to love it, with world design and enemy placement that fall short of the series' best.

Dragon Age: Inquisition

3.5

2014 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Dragon Age: Inquisition is a sprawling RPG with strong companion writing, a satisfying power fantasy, and enough content to keep you occupied for over a hundred hours. It's also padded with open-world busywork that dilutes its best moments, and its combat sits in an awkward middle ground between tactical and action that never fully commits to either. The highs are impressive, but you'll wade through a lot of filler to reach them.

The Witcher

3.5

2019 · 4 Seasons · Netflix · Fantasy / Drama / Action

The Witcher arrived on Netflix with massive potential and delivered on enough of it to build a loyal following, even as it frustrated fans of the source material at nearly every turn. Henry Cavill's commitment to Geralt elevated the first three seasons into something worth watching despite uneven writing and confusing timelines. The show's action sequences and monster designs remain impressive, and the core relationships between Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri carry real emotional weight when the scripts let them breathe. But creative liberties with the books, inconsistent pacing, and the looming question of how the series handles its lead actor transition make this a show that's easier to admire in pieces than as a whole.

Darkest Dungeon II

3.5

2023 · Roguelike RPG · PC / Steam

Darkest Dungeon II is a bold, polarizing sequel that trades the base-building loop of its predecessor for a tighter roguelike structure built around doomed road trips. The turn-based combat is excellent, the atmosphere is oppressive in all the right ways, and the relationship system adds a layer of strategy that can make or break a run. But the shift away from persistent progression alienates as many players as it attracts, and the run length can test patience when things spiral. If you can accept it as its own thing rather than measuring it against the original, there's a deeply rewarding tactical game here.

Diablo IV

3.5

2023 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Diablo IV delivers an excellent campaign and a dark, atmospheric world that fans waited years to explore. The combat feels responsive, the classes are distinct, and the production values are among the highest in the genre. What follows that campaign is where opinions split. Endgame content, seasonal depth, and an expensive cosmetic shop have kept the community in a state of perpetual debate about whether the game lives up to its potential. It's a good action RPG with a great foundation that hasn't yet figured out how to keep its most dedicated players satisfied long-term.

Wolcen: Lords of Mayhem

3.0

2020 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Wolcen: Lords of Mayhem is a cautionary tale wrapped in gorgeous packaging. Its visuals remain among the best the ARPG genre has produced, its Gate of Fates passive system is an inventive take on character building, and the voiced campaign shows more ambition than most games in this space attempt. But persistent bugs, balance problems that funnel players into a narrow set of viable endgame builds, and the end of all development and multiplayer support in 2024 leave it as a single-player curiosity rather than a genre contender. There's a good game buried here for those willing to accept its limitations, but the ceiling it could have reached makes its reality sting.

Raid: Shadow Legends

3.0

2018 · RPG / Gacha

Raid: Shadow Legends delivers some of the best character art and turn-based combat on mobile, with a champion roster deep enough to sustain years of team-building experimentation. The gear system adds genuine strategic depth, and clan boss fights create satisfying cooperative goals. The monetization is among the most aggressive in mobile gaming, the grind becomes punishing at higher levels, and the gap between the game's production quality and its pricing practices creates a frustrating contradiction.

Dragon Age: The Veilguard

3.0

2024 · Action RPG · PC / Steam

Dragon Age: The Veilguard is a polished action RPG with strong production values and a character creator that sets a new standard for the genre. It also feels like a departure from what made Dragon Age distinctive, with simplified RPG systems, a tonal shift toward lighter fare, and choices that rarely carry meaningful weight. It's a competent game that struggles to justify the decade-long wait.