Skip to content
Tags / Supernatural

Supernatural

42 BuzzVerdicts, ranked by rating across Movies (14), PC Games (5), TV Shows (19), Books (1), Mobile Games (3)

All Supernatural BuzzVerdicts

Mob Psycho 100

4.5

2016 · 3 Seasons · Crunchyroll · Animation / Action / Comedy / Supernatural

Mob Psycho 100 is one of the rare anime that gets better with every season and sticks the landing when it matters most. It wraps profound messages about self-acceptance and emotional growth inside some of the most inventive animation the medium has produced, and it does it without ever feeling like it's lecturing you. The humor is sharp, the action is spectacular, and the heart underneath it all is completely genuine. Three seasons wasn't many, but the show used every one of those 37 episodes to say exactly what it wanted to say.

anime action comedy supernatural

The Exorcist

4.5

1973 · William Friedkin · 122 min · Horror

The Exorcist set the template for serious horror filmmaking and more than fifty years later, nothing has fully displaced it from that position. William Friedkin built something that functions as both a deeply unsettling horror film and a thoughtful exploration of faith under pressure. Modern audiences may not find it as terrifying as the people who lined up around the block in 1973, but the craft, the performances, and the willingness to treat its subject matter with intelligence rather than exploitation continue to set it apart. It's slower and more demanding than most horror films that followed it, and that's a feature, not a flaw.

horror classic 1970s supernatural

Oxenfree (Mobile)

4.3

2016 · Adventure / Narrative

Oxenfree on mobile brings one of indie gaming's best narrative adventures to touchscreens with natural-feeling controls and a story that rewards multiple playthroughs. The walk-and-talk dialogue system creates relationships that feel authentic, and the supernatural mystery on Edwards Island builds tension through atmosphere and excellent sound design. The pacing can feel slow during traversal, and the game's quieter moments may test mobile players used to faster experiences. But the writing, voice acting, and choice-driven narrative create something genuinely special that works beautifully on a phone.

adventure narrative supernatural premium

Death Note

4.3

2006 · 1 Season · Nippon Television · Psychological Thriller / Crime / Supernatural

Death Note's first 25 episodes deliver one of the most gripping intellectual duels in anime history, carried by a brilliant premise and two unforgettable characters locked in a battle of wits. The final stretch can't maintain that standard, introducing replacements who never fill the void left by what came before. That unevenness keeps it from perfection, but it doesn't erase what the show accomplished at its peak. For anyone curious about anime or hungry for a psychological thriller that treats its audience as smart, this remains one of the best entry points the medium has ever produced.

anime thriller psychological crime

The Leftovers

4.3

2014 · 3 Seasons · HBO · Drama / Mystery

The Leftovers is one of the most emotionally powerful television shows ever made, a series that uses an impossible event as a lens for exploring grief, faith, and the desperate human need to make meaning from loss. The first season is heavy and challenging in ways that turn some viewers away. Seasons two and three represent a dramatic creative leap, delivering television so confident and emotionally devastating that it transforms the entire series into something extraordinary. This is a show that asks for patience and rewards it with an experience that stays with you long after the final episode ends.

drama HBO 2010s grief

What We Do in the Shadows

4.2

2019 · 6 Seasons · FX · Comedy, Horror, Mockumentary

What We Do in the Shadows took a cult film premise and stretched it across six seasons of increasingly absurd vampire comedy without ever losing its bite. The ensemble cast found new ways to mine laughs from centuries-old undead roommates navigating modern Staten Island, and the show's willingness to go bigger and weirder with each season kept it from settling into a comfortable rut. Some later seasons pushed the absurdity past the point where the emotional stakes could keep up, and the mockumentary format occasionally felt more like habit than intention. But at its best, this was one of the funniest shows on television, a comedy that made immortality feel hilariously mundane.

vampires mockumentary FX comedy

Jujutsu Kaisen

4.2

2020 · 3 Seasons · MBS / TBS · Action / Dark Fantasy / Supernatural

Jujutsu Kaisen delivers some of the best animated action sequences in modern anime, powered by a creative magic system and a willingness to let its characters suffer real consequences. MAPPA's production work is frequently stunning, and the show's refusal to pad itself with filler keeps the pace tight across its run. Its villain roster beyond the top tier can feel underdeveloped, and certain character arcs get cut short before they fully land. Still, this is a series that earns its place in the modern shounen conversation through sheer craft, ambition, and an appetite for darkness that most of its peers won't touch.

anime dark fantasy supernatural action

Oxenfree II: Lost Signals (Mobile)

4.1

2023 · Adventure / Narrative

Oxenfree II: Lost Signals builds on the original's atmospheric strengths with a more mature protagonist, expanded world, and a walkie-talkie communication system that deepens the narrative. The supernatural mystery across Camena's coastal landscapes is gripping, and the relationship between Riley and Jacob evolves through player choices in ways that feel authentic. The pacing has the same deliberate quality as the original, and the expanded scope occasionally stretches the narrative thin. But it's a worthy sequel that proves the Oxenfree formula works just as well with adult characters facing adult fears.

adventure narrative supernatural premium

Drag Me to Hell

4.0

2009 · Sam Raimi · 99 min · Horror

Drag Me to Hell is Sam Raimi doing what Sam Raimi does best: turning horror into a carnival ride that's equal parts terrifying and hilarious. His return to the genre after a decade of Spider-Man films proved he hadn't lost a step, delivering a PG-13 film that's more inventive and viscerally entertaining than most R-rated horror of its era. Alison Lohman anchors the chaos as a loan officer cursed by an elderly woman, and the film's willingness to be simultaneously gross, funny, and deeply unsettling gives it an energy that never lets up.

horror supernatural 2000s curse

Candyman

4.0

1992 · Bernard Rose · 99 min · Horror

Candyman stands apart from nearly every horror film of its era by grounding its supernatural threat in real social conditions that are more disturbing than any monster. Bernard Rose adapted Clive Barker's short story and relocated it to the Cabrini-Green housing project in Chicago, creating a horror film that's as much about institutional neglect, racial violence, and the stories communities tell to make sense of suffering as it is about a hook-handed specter. Tony Todd's performance as the title character is one of horror's great achievements, tragic and terrifying in equal measure.

horror supernatural 1990s classic

Dandadan

4.0

2024 · 1 Season · MBS / TBS · Supernatural / Action / Comedy / Romance

Dandadan throws ghosts, aliens, teenage romance, and absurdist comedy into a blender and somehow produces something that feels completely coherent. Science SARU's animation is jaw-dropping, the chemistry between its leads carries real emotional weight alongside the chaos, and the show's willingness to be weird without apologizing for it makes every episode feel unpredictable. The breakneck pacing occasionally leaves character development behind, and certain mature elements won't land for everyone. But as a pure shot of creative energy, Dandadan is the most exciting new anime to arrive in 2024.

anime supernatural comedy romance

Hereditary

4.0

2018 · Ari Aster · 127 min · Horror / Drama / Mystery

Hereditary is a deeply unsettling horror film that earns its scares through character and atmosphere rather than cheap tricks. Toni Collette delivers a performance that would be the centerpiece of any prestige drama, and Ari Aster's direction creates a sense of dread so thick it becomes almost physical. The final act's shift into supernatural territory loses some viewers who connected more deeply with the family drama, and the film's pacing demands patience that not all horror audiences are willing to give. But when it works, and for most of its runtime it works extraordinarily well, Hereditary feels like something new in a genre that rarely surprises anymore. It doesn't just scare you. It disturbs you on a level that's hard to shake.

horror A24 Ari Aster Toni Collette

Oxenfree

4.0

2016 · Narrative Adventure · PC / Steam

Oxenfree is a masterclass in interactive dialogue, wrapped in a supernatural mystery that's creepy, human, and surprisingly moving. Its real-time conversation system makes every interaction feel natural in a way that most narrative games don't even attempt. The characters talk like actual teenagers, the radio mechanic adds a tactile layer to the supernatural elements, and the branching paths give you real reasons to play through more than once. Gameplay beyond the dialogue is limited, and some players will find the pacing too leisurely. But as a narrative experience that trusts its writing and respects its characters, Oxenfree punches well above its weight.

narrative adventure supernatural dialogue

Buffy the Vampire Slayer

4.0

1997 · 7 Seasons · The WB, UPN · Fantasy / Drama

Buffy the Vampire Slayer took a campy premise and turned it into one of the most influential shows of its era, blending supernatural action with coming-of-age drama in ways that still resonate. Sarah Michelle Gellar anchors the whole thing with a performance that balances humor, vulnerability, and toughness across seven seasons. The show is uneven, with a rough first season and a divisive sixth, and some of its creative choices haven't aged as gracefully as others. At its best, though, this is a show that earns every bit of the devotion its fanbase still carries, delivering individual episodes and character arcs that stand among television's finest.

fantasy drama 1990s supernatural

The Witch

3.9

2015 · Robert Eggers · 92 min · Horror, Drama

The Witch is the kind of horror film that gets under your skin without ever rushing. Robert Eggers built something genuinely rare here: a debut feature with a fully realized world, a committed cast, and a willingness to let dread accumulate slowly rather than reach for cheap thrills. It won't satisfy viewers looking for scares on a schedule, but for those who let it work on them, it's haunting in ways that linger for days.

robert-eggers a24 folk-horror period-piece

Bleach

3.8

2004 · 16 Seasons · TV Tokyo · Action / Fantasy / Supernatural

Bleach is a pillar of shonen anime that delivers iconic characters, stylish combat, and some of the most memorable moments in the genre's history. The original run is hampered by excessive filler and uneven pacing, but the Thousand-Year Blood War revival represents a stunning return that addresses many of the original's shortcomings. Taken together, it's a sprawling epic with towering highs and frustrating lows that rewards fans who can navigate around its filler content.

anime shonen action supernatural

Carnivale

3.8

2003 · 2 Seasons · HBO · Fantasy, Drama, Mystery

Carnivale is one of the most visually stunning and atmospherically rich shows HBO ever produced, a Depression-era supernatural drama that built its mythology with patience and precision across two mesmerizing seasons. Daniel Knauf's creation features some of the finest production design in television history, with Clancy Brown delivering a performance as the sinister Brother Justin that commands every scene he inhabits. The slow pacing and dense mythology tested viewer patience, and the cancellation after two of a planned six seasons means the story remains permanently unfinished. But what exists is unlike anything else on television, a haunting and beautiful piece of work that rewards viewers willing to meet it on its own terms.

Daniel Knauf HBO fantasy Depression era

Us

3.8

2019 · Jordan Peele · 116 min · Horror, Thriller

Us is a bold, unsettling film that works better as an experience than as a puzzle. Lupita Nyong'o delivers one of the most committed dual performances horror has seen in years, and Peele demonstrates a genuine gift for sustained dread. The mythology doesn't survive close inspection, and the third act asks a lot of patience, but the film's images and ideas linger far longer than its plot holes. For audiences willing to meet it on its own terms, it's a disturbing, ambitious ride.

jordan-peele doppelganger social-commentary supernatural

Wednesday

3.8

2022 · 2 Seasons · Netflix · Supernatural Mystery / Comedy

Wednesday takes a beloved character and drops her into a teen mystery format that works better than it probably should. Jenna Ortega's deadpan performance carries the show through weaker plotting and some casting choices that don't quite land. The gothic visuals are gorgeous, the humor hits more often than it misses, and Ortega's chemistry with Emma Myers gives the show a genuine emotional core. The mysteries themselves are the weakest link, often predictable and occasionally convoluted, and the Addams Family elements beyond Wednesday herself feel undercooked. It's a fun, stylish show that knows what it does best and mostly sticks to it.

supernatural mystery comedy Netflix

Lucifer

3.5

2016 · 6 Seasons · Netflix · Urban Fantasy Procedural

Lucifer is a show that runs entirely on the charisma of Tom Ellis and the entertaining absurdity of watching the literal Devil solve crimes in Los Angeles. When it leans into the theological and emotional depths of its premise, it's surprisingly compelling television. When it falls back on repetitive procedural structures and drawn-out romantic tension, it tests the patience of even its most devoted fans. Six seasons is too many, but Ellis makes nearly every episode watchable, and the show's best stretches demonstrate that there was a genuinely great show hiding inside a good one.

fantasy procedural Netflix Fox

Hellraiser

3.5

1987 · Clive Barker · 94 min · Horror

Hellraiser brought a literary intelligence to 1980s horror that the genre desperately needed, creating iconography that has endured for decades through sheer force of imagination. Clive Barker's directorial debut took his own novella and translated its fusion of pain, pleasure, and obsession into a film that feels unlike anything else in the horror canon. The Cenobites, particularly Doug Bradley's Pinhead, became instant icons, but the film's real power comes from its willingness to treat desire and its consequences as something more complex than simple morality.

horror supernatural 1980s classic

True Blood

3.5

2008 · 7 Seasons · HBO · Horror / Fantasy / Drama

A wild, blood-soaked ride through supernatural Louisiana that started as a sharp metaphor for civil rights wrapped in Southern Gothic horror and gradually became the most entertaining mess on premium cable. Alan Ball's adaptation of the Sookie Stackhouse novels delivered unforgettable characters, a fearless approach to sex and violence, and a world so overstuffed with supernatural creatures that the show eventually buckled under their combined weight. The first three seasons are legitimately great television. Everything after that is a test of how much you enjoy chaos.

vampire supernatural HBO 2000s

Manifest

3.3

2018 · 4 Seasons · Netflix · Supernatural Drama

Manifest is a show that hooks you with one of the best premises in recent sci-fi television and then tests your patience by taking four seasons to explain it. The missing plane mystery and the 'callings' concept generate genuine intrigue, and the family drama provides an emotional anchor that keeps you watching through the rougher stretches. The network-TV pacing, repetitive plotting, and uneven writing hold it back from the heights its concept deserves, but the Netflix-revived final season provides enough answers to make the journey worthwhile for committed viewers.

supernatural mystery Netflix NBC