"Peter Jackson"

2013 · Peter Jackson · 161 min · Fantasy, Adventure

The Desolation of Smaug improves on its predecessor with better pacing and a magnificent dragon, but bloats itself with an unwanted love triangle and invented subplots that dilute Tolkien's story into something the author would barely recognize.

2012 · Peter Jackson · 169 min · Fantasy, Adventure

An Unexpected Journey delivers Martin Freeman's perfect Bilbo and one unforgettable cave scene, but stretches a slim source novel across three hours of padding, CGI excess, and tonal confusion that leaves fans debating whether the journey was worth taking at all.