Skip to content
Tags / New York

New York

30 BuzzVerdicts, ranked by rating across Movies (10), Books (6), TV Shows (12), Board Games (2)

All New York BuzzVerdicts

On the Waterfront

4.7

1954 · Elia Kazan · 108 min · Drama / Crime

On the Waterfront is the film where modern screen acting announces itself, with Marlon Brando's Terry Malloy setting a standard actors have chased for seventy years. Elia Kazan's dockside drama about a washed-up boxer caught between mob loyalty and his own conscience swept eight Academy Awards and still plays with startling force, from the taxi scene to the rooftop pigeon coops. Its history is complicated by Kazan's own testimony before Congress, a shadow that gives the film's argument for informing an uncomfortable charge. The filmmaking transcends the controversy. The performance transcends everything.

classic Marlon Brando Elia Kazan 1950s

Taxi Driver

4.7

1976 · Martin Scorsese · 114 min · Drama / Thriller

Martin Scorsese and Robert De Niro created one of the most unforgettable character studies in American cinema, a film that burrows into the psychology of loneliness and never flinches. Paul Schrader's screenplay gives shape to something most films won't touch, and Bernard Herrmann's final score wraps the whole thing in a mood you can't shake. The pacing demands patience, and the ending will leave you arguing with anyone who watched it with you. That's exactly why it still matters almost fifty years later.

drama thriller Scorsese 1970s

Mad Men

4.5

2007 · 7 Seasons · AMC · Drama

Mad Men built a seven-season character study inside a period piece so meticulously crafted that every costume, every set decoration, and every background detail earns its place on screen. Jon Hamm's Don Draper is a magnetic, frustrating, endlessly watchable creation, and the ensemble around him charts an entire decade of American transformation through individual lives rather than historical bullet points. The deliberate pacing is a genuine barrier for some viewers, and the later seasons retread familiar ground with diminishing returns. Those are fair criticisms of a show that still stands as one of the most ambitious and accomplished dramas in the history of the medium.

1960s advertising AMC drama

The Night Of

4.3

2016 · 1 Season · HBO · Crime Drama

The Night Of is one of HBO's finest limited series, a crime drama that uses a murder case to expose the machinery of the American justice system with devastating clarity. Riz Ahmed delivers a career-defining performance as a young man ground down by a system that presumes guilt, and John Turturro matches him as the unglamorous defense attorney carrying the weight of his client's life. The pacing demands patience, particularly in its middle stretch, but the cumulative payoff is a show that lingers in your mind long after the final episode.

drama crime HBO limited series

Kitchen Confidential

4.2

2000 · Anthony Bourdain · 320 pages · Memoir

Anthony Bourdain's 2000 memoir ripped the curtain off the restaurant industry and revealed a world of chaos, addiction, brilliance, and terrible behavior that the dining public never saw. His voice is electric on the page, his stories are outrageous and frequently very funny, and his love for the craft of cooking comes through even when he's describing its worst excesses. Some of the shock value has faded with time, and the book's structure is loose in places. But Bourdain's writing has an energy and honesty that most food writing still can't touch, and reading it now carries an additional weight that he couldn't have anticipated.

memoir Anthony Bourdain food restaurant industry

The Knick

4.2

2014 · 2 Seasons · Cinemax · Medical Drama

The Knick is one of the most visually ambitious shows ever made for television, a period medical drama directed entirely by Steven Soderbergh that feels nothing like any period piece you've seen before. Clive Owen delivers a ferocious performance as a brilliant, self-destructive surgeon navigating the dawn of modern medicine in 1900s New York, and the show's willingness to confront the racism, corruption, and brutality of the era gives it a weight that transcends its genre. Its two seasons tell a complete story that rewards viewers who can handle its unflinching subject matter.

drama medical Cinemax period

Elf

4.1

2003 · Jon Favreau · 97 min · Comedy / Holiday

Elf is the last film to fight its way into the Christmas canon and stay there, a fish-out-of-water comedy about a human raised by elves loose in Manhattan, powered by Will Ferrell's total, shameless commitment to childlike joy. Jon Favreau shoots it with old-fashioned craft, forced perspective and stop-motion nodding to the specials it grew up on, and James Caan's grinch of a father gives the sugar its necessary salt. The third act wobbles into plot it doesn't need, and the sweetness is a lifestyle choice. Two decades of December rotations have delivered the verdict anyway. It's a classic, certified annually.

comedy Christmas Will Ferrell Jon Favreau

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

4.1

2017 · 5 Seasons · Amazon Prime Video · Comedy, Drama, Period

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is a gorgeously produced period comedy that lives and dies by its rapid-fire dialogue and Rachel Brosnahan's magnetic lead performance. Its first two seasons are exceptional television, with sharp writing, stunning production design, and a propulsive energy that makes each episode fly by. Later seasons repeat familiar story beats and lose some momentum, but the show never stops being entertaining to watch or beautiful to look at. A final season course-correction delivers a satisfying conclusion that honors the character's journey. If you love fast-talking comedies with heart and style to spare, Maisel delivers both in abundance.

period drama comedy stand-up 1950s

White Collar

4.1

2009 · 6 Seasons · USA Network · Crime, Comedy, Drama, Mystery

White Collar succeeds on the strength of its central partnership: Matt Bomer's suave con artist and Tim DeKay's straight-arrow FBI agent make an unlikely duo whose chemistry carries the show through six seasons of art heists, forgeries, and the ongoing question of whether a criminal can truly go straight. The cases are stylish and entertaining, Manhattan looks gorgeous, and the show maintains a lightness of touch that makes it endlessly rewatchable. The mythology around the music box and later conspiracies doesn't always land, but the core dynamic between Neal and Peter never falters.

USA Network Jeff Eastin crime con artist

The Nanny

4.0

1993 · 6 Seasons · CBS · Comedy

The Nanny is the flashy girl from Flushing conquering a Park Avenue mansion one animal-print outfit at a time, and three decades later the formula plays better than ever. Fran Drescher's cosmetics-counter Cinderella brings her voice, her wardrobe, and her mother's leftovers into the household of a stiff British producer, and the ensuing culture collision powered six seasons of Borscht Belt timing, couture-level costume design, and one of sitcom history's defining will-they-won't-theys. Streaming rediscovery turned it into a genuine cross-generational phenomenon. The broad laugh-track machinery and a soggy final season are the tax. The style, in every sense, is the payoff.

sitcom CBS 1990s Fran Drescher

Only Murders in the Building

4.0

2021 · 4 Seasons · Hulu · Comedy-Mystery

Only Murders in the Building is a charming, clever comedy-mystery that gets remarkable mileage out of the chemistry between Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez. Its true-crime-podcast premise is both a loving homage and a sharp satire, and the show's best seasons balance genuine whodunit tension with character comedy that lands consistently. Later seasons show some formula fatigue, cycling through new murders and celebrity guest stars with diminishing returns, but the central trio remains a delight and the show's warmth keeps it enjoyable even when the mysteries themselves lose some of their punch.

comedy mystery Hulu Steve Martin

Annie Hall

4.0

1977 · Woody Allen · 93 min · Comedy, Romance

Annie Hall changed what a romantic comedy could be, and its influence on the genre is hard to overstate. Diane Keaton's performance remains a high point of American screen comedy, and the film's structural inventiveness still feels fresh decades later. Alvy Singer's self-absorption limits the emotional range, and some of the cultural references have faded. But as a portrait of how relationships fall apart despite the best intentions of the people in them, it still finds the nerve.

comedy romance classic 1970s

The Seven Year Slip

3.9

2023 · Ashley Poston · Fiction / Romance

The Seven Year Slip hands a grieving book publicist her late aunt's magical New York apartment, a home that occasionally slips seven years into the past, and lets her fall for the aspiring chef renting the second bedroom back then, a man whose present-day self she could meet any time she's brave enough to look. Ashley Poston runs the impossible premise as a grief novel wearing a romance's clothes, lemon pies and pistachio-sauce mornings against the ache of a life on pause. The magic follows feelings rather than rules and the middle idles a loop too long. The landing, when it comes, earns the tears it collects.

romance magical realism New York grief

Begin Again

3.9

2013 · John Carney · 104 min · Music / Comedy Drama

Begin Again pairs a fired, day-drinking record executive with a heartbroken songwriter he overhears in a Manhattan open mic, and John Carney runs his signature thesis, music as the repair language for broken people, through an album recorded live across New York's streets, rooftops, and alleys. Keira Knightley's unshowy singing and Mark Ruffalo's rumpled fervor carry the film's real romance, a creative partnership the script wisely refuses to convert into a couple, and the outdoor recording sessions remain pure joy. The industry satire is soft, the ex-boyfriend pop-star subplot runs on caricature, and the gloss occasionally outshines the grit. The headphone-splitter walk endures.

music New York John Carney Keira Knightley

The Deuce

3.8

2017 · 3 Seasons · HBO · Drama / Crime

The Deuce is an ambitious chronicle of Times Square's transformation from the 1970s through the 1980s, tracking the intersection of the sex industry, organized crime, and the birth of the pornography business. David Simon and George Pelecanos bring their characteristic attention to systemic forces, and the show features strong performances and remarkable period detail, though its sprawling scope and challenging subject matter limit its accessibility.

drama HBO 2010s crime

The History of Love

3.8

2005 · Nicole Krauss · 252 pages · Literary Fiction

Nicole Krauss's The History of Love weaves together multiple storylines across decades and continents, connected by a lost manuscript about a young man's love for a girl named Alma. The novel is tender, inventive, and structurally ambitious, with characters who feel both specific and archetypal. Its fragmented narrative rewards patient readers, though some find the convergence of its various threads too tidy for a novel that spends most of its pages embracing messiness.

Nicole Krauss literary fiction Jewish American fiction love

Central Park

3.8

2020 · 3 Seasons · Apple TV+ · Animated Musical Comedy

Central Park is Loren Bouchard's musical follow-up to Bob's Burgers, and it brings the same family warmth and offbeat humor to an animated New York where a park manager's family sings their way through crises both domestic and municipal. The original songs are consistently strong, and the Tillerman family is an ensemble worth spending time with. Three seasons of steady quality make it a reliable comfort watch, even if it never quite achieves the heights of its creator's most celebrated work.

animated Apple TV+ 2020s musical comedy

Gangs of New York

3.8

2002 · Martin Scorsese · 167 min · Crime / Drama / Historical

Gangs of New York is a film built around one of the greatest screen villains ever committed to celluloid. Daniel Day-Lewis's Bill the Butcher is a towering creation that dominates every frame he occupies and exposes the limitations of everything around him. The historical recreation of Five Points Manhattan is staggering in its ambition and detail, but Leonardo DiCaprio's revenge plot can't support the weight Scorsese places on it, and the film's final act struggles to balance personal drama with historical spectacle. It's a flawed, fascinating epic that reaches higher than it can consistently grasp.

crime drama historical Martin Scorsese

How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days

3.7

2003 · Donald Petrie · 116 min · Romance / Comedy

How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days runs the genre's best dueling-deceptions premise, a columnist driving a man away for an article while he makes her fall in love for a bet, and neither knows they're both performing. Kate Hudson weaponizes clinginess with a comedian's precision, Matthew McConaughey absorbs the assault at full charm, and the film's spectacle of two professionals sabotaging each other into real feelings built a permanent rotation classic. The premise requires two liars the audience must forgive, the magazine world is pure cartoon, and the ending forgives faster than it should. The couple's fern outlived every objection.

rom-com Kate Hudson Matthew McConaughey 2000s

Night at the Museum

3.6

2006 · Shawn Levy · 108 min · Comedy / Fantasy

Night at the Museum runs family cinema's most field-trip-proof premise, a divorced dad takes the night-guard job at the natural history museum and discovers the exhibits wake at sundown, skeleton dinosaur playing fetch, miniature cowboys waging diorama war, and Robin Williams's wax Teddy Roosevelt dispensing courage from horseback. Ben Stiller plays the straight man to an entire building, the premise generates set pieces on demand, and the film's museums-are-cool evangelism did real institutional good. The plot is a training montage with a heist stapled on, the dad-redemption arc runs on autopilot, and the humor aims young. The capuchin slap fight remains undefeated.

family Ben Stiller Robin Williams 2000s