Skip to content
Tags / Book Club

Book Club

12 BuzzVerdicts, ranked by rating

All Book Club BuzzVerdicts

The Boys in the Boat

4.3

2013 · Daniel James Brown · 404 pages · Nonfiction / Sports

The Boys in the Boat rows nine working-class Washington students into the 1936 Berlin Olympics and became one of the decade's most beloved nonfiction books doing it. Daniel James Brown builds the story on Joe Rantz, a boy abandoned by his family who found in an eight-oared shell the belonging life had refused him, and the book's evocation of swing, the transcendent state where eight rowers become one motion, gives sports writing one of its loveliest ideas. The prose reaches golden-hour lyricism more often than some readers' tolerance allows and the Nazi pageantry stays backdrop. The final race still stops hearts on schedule.

nonfiction rowing Olympics 1930s

The Covenant of Water

4.2

2023 · Abraham Verghese · 736 pages · Fiction / Literary

The Covenant of Water follows three generations of a Kerala family afflicted by a strange inheritance, in every generation someone drowns, across seven decades of South Indian history, medicine, faith, and monsoon. Abraham Verghese, the physician-novelist, writes with a doctor's precision and a believer's patience, and readers who surrender to its unhurried river describe one of the decade's richest reading experiences, anchored by the matriarch Big Ammachi, one of recent fiction's great characters. It's 736 pages that could be shorter, dense with medical set pieces and coincidence-stitched plotting. Book clubs wept, skimmers bounced, and both were responding to the same design.

literary fiction India family saga Abraham Verghese

The Frozen River

4.2

2023 · Ariel Lawhon · 432 pages · Fiction / Historical

The Frozen River builds a propulsive frontier mystery around a real woman history nearly forgot, Martha Ballard, the Maine midwife whose decades of meticulous diary-keeping made her one of early America's best-documented ordinary lives. Ariel Lawhon's 1789 winter runs a body under the river ice into a rape trial's tangled aftermath, with Martha's midwife authority, her diary, and her stubborn sense of testimony driving both investigations. Book clubs made it a phenomenon, the marriage at its center is the genre's warmest in years, and the villainy runs mustache-twirl broad while Martha's sensibilities read more modern than her century. The ice holds anyway. This is historical crime done with real spine.

historical fiction mystery midwife 18th century

The Bee Sting

4.2

2023 · Paul Murray · 656 pages · Fiction / Literary

The Bee Sting is a 650-page Irish family tragicomedy that reads like a thriller assembled from four unreliable hearts, the Barnes family's garage business failing while father, mother, daughter, and son each narrate the private catastrophe the others can't see. Paul Murray rotates the perspectives with escalating dread, secrets stacking toward a finale readers have argued about since publication, an ending that either perfects the book's design or abandons its readers at the worst possible moment, depending on which thread of the argument you join. Booker-shortlisted, list-topping, and honestly funny on the road to devastating. The length asks commitment. The last page asks more.

literary fiction family saga Ireland Paul Murray

Martyr!

4.2

2024 · Kaveh Akbar · 352 pages · Fiction / Literary

Martyr! announced poet Kaveh Akbar as a major novelist with one of the most celebrated debuts of its year, the story of Cyrus Shams, a newly sober Iranian-American poet obsessed with making his death mean something, whose research into martyrs leads him to a terminally ill artist spending her final days as a museum installation. It's a novel about addiction, grief, and the hunger for significance that manages to be riotously funny on the way to devastating, with sentences that carry a poet's charge. The dream interludes divide readers and the ending leans on a convergence some find too neat. The voice converts nearly everyone.

literary fiction debut Iranian-American addiction

Remarkably Bright Creatures

4.1

2022 · Shelby Van Pelt · 355 pages · Fiction / Contemporary

Remarkably Bright Creatures stars the book-club era's most beloved narrator, Marcellus, a giant Pacific octopus serving a life sentence at a small-town aquarium, whose sardonic captivity journal braids around widowed Tova Sullivan's night-shift cleaning and a thirty-year-old mystery about her drowned son. Shelby Van Pelt's debut became a word-of-mouth phenomenon on pure charm, grief and loneliness handled with a light touch, and an interspecies friendship that earns its sentiment. The human plot resolves on coincidences visible from open water and the octopus out-writes every biped in the book. Readers noted both and recommended it to their mothers anyway.

fiction book club octopus debut

Carrie Soto Is Back

4.0

2022 · Taylor Jenkins Reid · Fiction / Sports Drama

Carrie Soto Is Back sends the greatest tennis player of her fictional era out of retirement at thirty-seven to defend her slam record from the rising star who just tied it, and Taylor Jenkins Reid builds from that premise the rare sports novel that treats a woman's ruthlessness as the point rather than the problem. Carrie is abrasive by design, her father-coach bond supplies the heart, and the match sequences read with genuine televised tension. The tennis arc lands exactly where sports stories land, and the media's likability sermons get answered more tidily than real careers allow. As competitive fiction with an unapologetic engine, it aces its service game.

tennis Taylor Jenkins Reid sports comeback

First Lie Wins

4.0

2024 · Ashley Elston · 352 pages · Fiction / Thriller

First Lie Wins runs its thriller from the con artist's side of the table, Evie Porter, a professional identity with a real woman underneath, embedded in a Louisiana boyfriend's life on her shadowy employer's orders, until a stranger at a dinner party shows up wearing her real name. Ashley Elston's adult debut became the book-club thriller of its season on pure construction, timelines braided, cons nested, every reveal re-dealing the deck, and the heroine's competence makes a genre usually built on victims run instead on chess. The plausibility strains if audited and the villain's endgame resolves neater than the setup promised. Nobody audits mid-ride. That's the con, and it works.

thriller con artist mystery book club

Funny Story

4.0

2024 · Emily Henry · Fiction / Romance

Funny Story opens on romance's cruelest setup, a woman whose fiance leaves her for his childhood best friend, stranding her in his Michigan lake town, and solves it with the genre's most satisfying arithmetic, she moves in with the other jilted half, her ex's new fiancee's ex-boyfriend. Emily Henry runs the fake-dating machinery through her signature banter and a heroine rebuilding an identity outsourced to other people's plans, and Miles, the golden-retriever roommate with hidden bruises, joins the genre's beloved-lead shortlist. The beats arrive on genre schedule and the town runs on postcard economics. As summer-read engineering, it's Henry at cruising altitude, which is the genre's ceiling.

romance Emily Henry fake dating Michigan

None of This Is True

4.0

2023 · Lisa Jewell · 368 pages · Fiction / Thriller

None of This Is True begins with two women sharing a birthday in a pub, and ends with one of them living in the other's house, the podcast between them recording every step of the invasion. Lisa Jewell's birthday-twins thriller runs on the queasiest engine in the genre, a stranger's confessions that might be griefs, lies, or bait, delivered to a podcaster whose platform converts listening into complicity. The mixed-media structure, podcast transcripts and documentary fragments braided through the narration, keeps the truth permanently disputed, and the title's warning applies to every chapter it precedes. The ending divides on arrival, resolution traded for unease. That unease is the product, and it lingers for days.

thriller psychological Lisa Jewell podcast

The Seven Year Slip

3.9

2023 · Ashley Poston · Fiction / Romance

The Seven Year Slip hands a grieving book publicist her late aunt's magical New York apartment, a home that occasionally slips seven years into the past, and lets her fall for the aspiring chef renting the second bedroom back then, a man whose present-day self she could meet any time she's brave enough to look. Ashley Poston runs the impossible premise as a grief novel wearing a romance's clothes, lemon pies and pistachio-sauce mornings against the ache of a life on pause. The magic follows feelings rather than rules and the middle idles a loop too long. The landing, when it comes, earns the tears it collects.

romance magical realism New York grief

The Guest List

3.8

2020 · Lucy Foley · 320 pages · Fiction / Thriller

The Guest List strands a magazine-perfect wedding on a storm-lashed Irish island and runs the classic locked-room formula with a modern structural twist, the victim's identity withheld as long as the killer's. Lucy Foley rotates five narrators, bride, plus-one, best man, wedding planner, bridesmaid, each nursing secrets that converge on one body in the dark, and the book's atmosphere, peat bogs, gull screams, champagne curdling into menace, carries its bestseller momentum honestly. The characters run archetypal and the reveals stack coincidence high. As a one-sitting storm read, though, it does exactly what the cover promises, and book clubs devoured it for good reason.

thriller mystery wedding island